EXPECTATION FROM A COURT DECISION AS A TYPE OF PROPERTY EXPECTATION IN CIVIL LAW

Authors

  • Dmytro Lutsenko "Novels" Bar Association

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.51989/NUL.2024.3.15

Keywords:

property expectations, civil law, court decision, assessment of property expectations, protection of property expectations, modern civil legislation, court practice.

Abstract

Expectation from a court decision as a type of property expectation in civil law is a complex and multifaceted phenomenon that requires detailed analysis and research. This concept covers various aspects of legal theory and practice, including the legal nature, recognition criteria, legal consequences and mechanisms for the protection of property expectations. This article covers key aspects of this issue, including the definition of property expectations, their classification and role in civil proceedings. Property expectations from a court decision can be defined as the legitimate hopes of the parties to receive a certain property result from the court process. These expectations arise on the basis of legal norms and facts substantiating the claims of the parties, and they can have significant economic and legal consequences. The legal nature of property expectations remains a subject of debate in legal science. Some researchers consider them as subjective rights to be protected, while others consider them only as legal expectations that do not create independent rights. Determining the legal nature of property expectations is key to understanding their legal status and opportunities for protection. The criteria for recognizing property expectations from a court decision include the existence of legal grounds for expectations, the validity of claims, and the existence of real chances of obtaining the desired result. Case law plays an important role in determining these criteria, forming precedents and legal positions that affect the stability of the legal system. The legal consequences of the recognition of property expectations can be diverse. They may include compensation for loss of expected benefits, protection against wrongdoing by other parties, and enforcement of judgments. For example, if the court recognizes the expectation of receiving compensation for damage caused by an unconscionable act, the property expectation can be ensured by a decision to recover the corresponding amount. Recognition of property expectations also affects the rights and obligations of the parties, determining their legal status and opportunities to protect their interests. Protection of property expectations is an important aspect of civil law. Parties can go to court to protect their expectations using various legal mechanisms, such as claims for recognition of rights, damages, seizure of property, etc. Effective protection of property expectations requires improvement of legislation and law enforcement practice. Practical aspects of the realization of rights to property expectations include the resolution of specific disputes, the application of legal norms and the provision of a fair trial. In practice, numerous problems arise, such as legal uncertainty, difficulty of proof, and conflicts of interest. Solving these problems is an important task for ensuring the stability and predictability of legal relations. Summing up, property expectations from a court decision are an important element of civil law that requires deep scientific research and the development of effective legal mechanisms for their protection. This will contribute to the improvement of legal culture, protection of the rights and interests of participants in court proceedings, and strengthening of the legal system as a whole.

References

Цивільний кодекс України № 435-IV від 16.01.2003. Верховна Рада України. Офіційний сайт. Дата оновлення : 27.04.2024. URL : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/435-15#Text

Постанова Верховного Суду від 13 квітня 2021 року у справі № 910/11702/18. Судова влада України. URL : https://supreme.court.gov.ua/supreme/pro_sud/rishennya_sud_palat_kgs_vs/2021_04_13_910_11702_18

Аналіз деяких питань застосування судами законодавства про право власності при розгляді цивільних справ : Лист Верховного Суду України від 01.07.2013. Ліга 360. URL : https://ips.ligazakon.net/document/VSS00069

Бесага І. В. Методологічне значення категорії «правомірного очікування» Вернера Майхофера для судової практики Верховного Суду. Філософія права і загальна теорія права. 2022. № 1. С. 67‒79.

Визнання майнових прав на об`єкт незавершеного будівництва. Адвокат Морозов Євген Олександрович. URL : https://alibi.dp.ua/2327-viznannya-majnovikh-prav-na-ob-ektnezavershenogo-budivnitstva

Кисіль В. Право очікування: транскрипції змісту. Юридична газета онлайн. 12.02.2019. № 7 (661). URL : https://yur-gazeta.com/publications/practice/neruhomist-ta-budivnictvo/pravo-ochikuvannya-transkripciyi-zmistu.html

Поворот виконання рішення суду у цивільній справі. Безоплатна правнича допомога. URL : http://surl.li/uczpj

Пояснювальна записка до контрольного переліку показників тайм менеджменту. м. Страсбург, 16 червня 2023 року. URL : https://supreme.court.gov.ua/supreme/pokaznikidiyalnosti/mign_standart/2023_06_30_pojasnen_kontr_perelik

Сліпченко С. О. Поняття законних очікувань як різновиду майна. Форум Права. 2020. № 62 (3). С. 66–76.

Pound R. Jurisprudence. Part I. Clark, N.J.: The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd., 1959. 3258 p.

Published

2024-08-12

Issue

Section

TOPICAL ISSUES OF PRIVATE LAW